Au contraire, your reply is incredibly helpful.
I’m not playing live, but I try to record as much as possible live-to-disk.
Partly because I find editing and mixing in a DAW always feels like a chore and kills my workflow. Partly because I try to compose things that I could conceivably play live with only 1 or 2 other musicians.
Though now your reply, and Dave’s videos, actually lead me to wonder if my issue is the opposite to what you describe—that I’m not hitting the comp hard enough, or, really that I’m not running my sources nearly hot enough into my mixer in the first place.
Here’s why I think this: I usually have to turn the threshold on any FMR device well below -20 to get it to react when I run stuff out from my mixer. I never turn it above -10.
That ends up giving me a really tiny window to find a sweet spot on each song, which sucks. Not much room to play between no engagement and total squashage.
I notice this on the PBC too—i.e. I need to really crank the “Input” knob for it to engage.
I also notice I usually have to turn the Output way down to match the bypass level. Most folks I see turn this up, so I must be doing something wrong.
FWIW I almost always employ AdamJay’s high-pass sidechain method to strip most of the low bass from the signal, except I use a cheap 3-band parametric EQ pedal instead of an inline widget thingie. Otherwise I find FMR boxes don’t seem usable for any music with ass-shake appeal.
Oh, I guess I should answer the Q of why use compression at all.
First, I often find my DT sounds less lively on playback than during recording. Mixing in a compressed signal seems to make up for this deadening effect.
Second, I’ve found that mixing Korg and Elektron gear is a gain-staging nightmare, because all my korgs have insane dynamic peaks and valleys.
That’s what I meant by “glue” . . . Making sure the DT, Korg and my Fender J all share some dynamic quality and don’t step all over each other.
Your response makes me think I need to change my order of operations and really limit the Korgs before I do anything else.