After only a day or two I like the Model 12 much more. This is 100% because of how I make music and not due to build quality issues or anything. The Bluebox a solid, well designed box with a fantastic UI.
But I tend to build up songs in layers and don’t really know where I’m going with them until I get there. The Model 12 is great for this because I can jump to a bar, loop playback, and even punch in if I want.
But the Bluebox, as others have mentioned, lacks any sort of ability to playback or loop from anything but the start of a track. This turns out to be way more painful for me than I would have thought.
In a way, it’s is very Elektron-like. On Elektron gear, all patterns always play back from the beginning and if you’re tweaking something on page 4, it’s like “come on!” right?
But now imagine if instead of finishing up the last of just four bars, you’re trying to write the final four bars of a 2:30 song staring from the beginning each time. Ick!
I’ve tried a few different things, like recording smaller, pattern-like sections so starting from the “start” isn’t such an issue. But there’s no way to “chain” these on the Bluebox, so I hear everything together for the first time in my daw, and I find my transitions don’t work as well as I thought and I’m missing parts and… (and at this point, I should probably be using a blackbox instead but I want the EQ and mix stuff).
So I don’t know. It’s portable, but the Zoom R24 is a similar weight and only 2x as large (still 1/3 the size and a mere fraction of the weight of the Model 12). For the same price, the R24 can take a mic or guitar, runs off of batteries, has a ton of editing, trimming, and looping capabilities, physical controls, and throws in a junky drum machine
But both the build quality and UI of the R24 are a disaster, so I still hold out hope for the Bluebox. Lots of people are talking about looping and punch-in and I think that would solve 95% of my issues and is doable with firmware. But right now, the Bluebox is a very good mixer and a bad multitracker. So nothing is replacing my Model 12 at the moment.