Hi all,
So I’m trying to update my setup to move more from live improv jamming into song production. While I’m enjoying just building grooves on the fly I feel there are a few things missing in my current setup:
- Better arrangement workflow (not entirely vibing with the Electron sequencers for full arrangement)
- Mix down capabilities
- Individual sampling of sources on the fly
- Recording my jams
This would probably be easiest fixed by getting midi-out from my laptop and getting a multichannel audio card so I can arrange and record in a DAW but I would like to stay OTB as much as possible. For the arrangement part i’m considering adding an MPC One as the brain unit (just to see if the Akai workflow clicks better with me than the Octatrack does as a brain unit) but for the mixing/recording part I’m still unsure what would be the best route.
I currently have for sound sources:
Analog 4 MK1
Analog Rytm MK1
Digitone
Small modular
Behringer TD-3
For sampling/mangling I have:
Octatrack MK1
and for FX:
Analog Heat MKII
I have the AR hooked up to A/B on Octatrack, Modular and TD-3 feed into the A4, A4 feeds into Digitone, Digiton into C/D on Octatrack, Octatrack out to AH to speakers.
I would like to be able to mix every sound source individually and on the go be able to sample an individual sound source through the Octatrack. I would also like the option of being able to send individual channels to the Analog Heat via stereo send/return or maybe through other FX peddles in the future.
I’ve run it down to two types of units:
- Tascam Model 12/16
- Mackie 1402VLZ4/1642VLZ4
Ofcourse the Tascam’s are mostly interesting due to having multitrack recording available (which I would love to do OTB) and I really like the looks of the devices but I have the feeling that there are not enough signal routing options available on this device. In terms of routing options it seems the Tascam Model 16 is comparable to the Mackie 1402VLZ4 (though without the stereo return input’s). Both seem to allow for a selection of channels to be outputted to the Octatrack (Alt3/4 on Mackie, Sub-Out on Tascam) for sampling if I am correct? Both seem to have two mono aux send’s post-fader. Unfortunately with the lack of stereo returns on the Tascam it seems I’ll have to sacrifice input channel’s which are already not in large supply.
Considering current sound sources I need at least 10 channel input (2 for A4, 2 for Rytm, 2 for Digitone, 1 for modular, 1 for TD-3, 2 for Octatrack Main out) there won’t be enough space on the Model 12 to feed any FX send back into the device. On the Model 16 there are two more channels (and the 13/14 stereo channel which I am not sure can be used for this) but then I would still be at my very limit and from what I’ve read it seems that the Midi functionality of the Tascam Model 12 can be quite useful to record extra layers afterwards.
So it seems that the Tascam Model 12/16 just does not have enough routing options to include the Ocatrack and an FX chain on it. The Mackie 1402 does seem to offer a bit more flexibility having stereo returns and more stereo input channels but of course then no multitrack recording OTB and there is still only two aux sends and one subgroup available.
If I go the Mackie route than for future safety it seems the 1642 VLZ4 is by far the best option if I forgo the recording capability. Multiple sub-outs would allow to incorporate the MPC One into the flow and send channels out to either the Octatrack on one subgroup, or the MPC on another subgroup for sampling. And it also has a Master insert for the Analog Heat and 4 Aux sends (though I assume these are mono aux sends and can not be used as stereo aux sends when the source channel is a stereo channel as it would get summed into mono on the aux bus?). I’m assuming the Analog Heat is best served with a stereo signal but other fx (boss space echo, strymon big sky) probably work just as well with mono input and stereo output?
So I guess the 1642 is the way to go, as been recommended more often here on this forum, but the Tascam is just so attractive to me and I just wish there would be aux return and master insert options so that it would play well with the AH and an external reverb fx. I can do without extra sub-groups (so either no MPC One or chain this after the Octatrack) but the lack of FX routing options just seems like it’s not the right option.
Anyone has some smart solutions or personal experiences with a similar setup?