*disclaimer writing this on phone
Rev2 16 voice is an excellent synth and excels in the modulation department. Rev2 is so much fun with the layers. My own personal opinion is that the synth is overly bright, jarring, and sterile. I don’t like how it takes 2-3 LFOS and the VCM sequencer lane trick JUST to get the sound lively and less sterile.
I like very basic sounds that have been proven over the years are easy to make typically, but I find it cumbersome to dig in on the Rev2. The Curtis filter is great at times but I feel the sweet spot is extremely limited (for my uses anyway). I love the keybed.
The Take5 reminds me more of the P6 I had. Never owned both (P6+T5) simultaneously but I am reminded of the warmth and ease of use. The sweet spot on the Take5 is wide. Very easy to dial in the type of sounds I love.
The Take5 filter to me is way more musical. It can do excellent leads, lush pads, and thick bass actually, with very minimal effort. The keybed doesn’t bother me but I can see why people would want more keys.
The Take5 filter drive is interesting. With resonance it squeals but in a pleasing way. And the more you push drive, the squeal levels out and almost goes away. There must be some level compensation trickery going on inside?
Personally, I find the Take5 filter design way more interesting. No question. I am a big fan of the brassy nature found in the Rev2 (I know some hate that) but you can easily do similar on the Take5.
I wanted a compact poly synth for moving workspaces around the house and the Take5 is perfect for that. I think these are very different synths and either are a great addition to a rig. One certainly doesn’t make the other redundant.
I built a smallish rig in the living room for while away from the main studio area and the Take5 handles all the various duties perfectly. I’m beyond impressed.
The type of music I like for example is: Kamaal Williams, Devonwho, DamFunk, B Bravo, Teebs, Mndsgn, Sasac etc.
Summary for those too lazy to read everything:
decide if you want modulation/keybed or tone/portability. Those are the deciding points IMO.
Biggest con for Rev2 is the required work to just get usable sounds.
Biggest con for Take5 is fact there are only 5 voices and 2 LFOS.
But they are different machines for sure, obviously.