This is mostly true. I mean I feel like plugins can’t get close to the real sound of certain analog polys or what you can make when you have that raw electronic power in your hands, in the physical world
But vcv rack is an incredible learning tool. I learned how to use sequential switches to make my own sort of “wavetables” or my own modulation sequencers. I learned how fm works, I even learned how the typical subtractive synth layout works with envelopes to filters & vcas with the vco at the beginning and the clock driving everything. I learned how turing machines work, learned to use marbles & stages.I learned how to make physically modelled strings with a delay and a filter plus a noise burst exciter using karplus-strong. And reverse-engineering the plaits modes taught me so much about physical modeling synthesis as well. You have all the elements you need in Rack
I wouldn’t have known what type of filter I wanted, that you could ping filters and phasers, what was going to drive my sequencers, how much and what type of modulation I wanted, what I’d need in terms of vcas or attenuation/attenuvertors and logic
Even the mixers in rack teach you about sends and returns with cv control for potentiometers. It’s a much greater one-to-one analog of what you’re going to encounter in a hardware setup than what you learn from a daw
You learn what you need. It’s like an interactive modulargrid which is pretty damn accurate in terms of sound and functionality. You realize what kind of tools you want for what you expect to build out of eurorack. and even more than that, you learn what is possible. You can learn teletype in there, you have a morphagene emulation, Erica synths, Befaco (muxlicer rules), all the mutable stuff, and much much more, all for free. You can get Maths for free, even
It’s worth a shot, if nothing else. Just install and play with it once. Take your modulargrid rack and build it in vcv to see if it works. Even if the exact module isn’t in there, I promise you’ll find something that does the exact same thing. I highly recommend grabbing every free module from the plugin manager & firing up an omri Cohen video
But I also did have an 0-Coast before I bought my little niftycase. And that did teach me that I needed a function generator that can do audio rate modulation (or a looping envelope). But I don’t see it as very useful for making music with. That’s just my own bias though. It is very cool and well thought out, obviously. But I think a Behringer monosynth typically is more useful.
I’m a big fan of the crave, but I never owned the mother 32. There’s a lot of patching to be done there, but you can’t do all the crazy things you’d expect from eurorack. It is useful for leads and especially bass. Such an amazing sounding analog monosynth
I see vcv rack as a sort of more interactive, easier to visualize version of max msp or pd. You can build whatever you want with more building blocks than you would ever know what to do with. Then, the cool part is that you can then translate all of those skills and tools into the real world once you become a millionaire
100%
In my case, I would have never known how useful most tools were, specifically Warps, if I wasn’t able to use it in Parasites in Vcv Rack before I bought the mystic circuits clone. That is hands down my favorite hardware effects tool that exists and now that I’m not using eurorack anymore, I’ve been searching for something that can do everything warps can outside of modular for a while
I also don’t think I would have any idea what to do with something like o_C had I not learned in vcv first. It would have been a much steeper learning curve for me