Excellent lists in this thread!
I think I’d need a top-50 list to fit my absolute favorites.
I’ll probably miss a lot, but I’ll put something rough together here Not a rigid top-10, but definitely a group of my favorites off the top of my head, and not necessarily in order. Missing a LOT of favorites.
1 . System Shock Series
2. M.U.L.E.
3. Archon
4. Ultima Series (Pagan is my favorite.)
5. Chrono Trigger
6. Zelda Series
7. Mario Series
8. Doom Series
9. Hollow Knight
10. Castlevania Series
That covers very little. Doesn’t touch Amiga games, many C64 favorites, Arcade favorites, fighters, etc. Metroids.
Riddick: Escape from Butcher Bay, Quake Series, Samurai Shodown Series, etc.
Too many excellent games over all systems. PC Engine has probably 50 favorites on its own
Some modern ones like Dishonored and Prey, and tons of Indie games like Fez, Hyper Light Drifter, etc. deserve mentioning too.
Robotron
Money Puzzle Exchanger
R-Type Series
Ghouls n Ghosts
Dimahoo
I forgot to add Terraria. I run a server for my family, and probably have 1000 hours in it building advanced worlds with my daughters. Rail systems above, below ground and in sky, tubes from bottom to sky, and crazy buildings everywhere, hanging sky gardens, etc. It’s interesting to watch the evolution since we all play at different times.